Willoughby's Coffee & Tea — Establishment, food and cafe at 258 Church Street, New Haven, Connecticut.

The efficient, polite staff will get your order right, and right away, each time, even when the line is long. The coffee is always fresh, with daily coffee specials and seasonal beverage offerings. There is a good selection of locally sourced baked goods and New York bagels to go with your beverage. This location is often busy and is VERY small, but if you are lucky enough to find a seat, take time to enjoy your coffee as you watch the world go by. The coffee is roasted at Willoughby’s Branford location. Willoughby’s does a mail order business; you can buy the same coffee and tea here, ground to order. With its large selection of coffee and tea brewing supplies, Willoughby’s t-shirts, local honey, and nicely bagged chocolate covered espresso beans, this is a great place to pick up a last-minute gift.